An atheist philosophy club at a college harasses Scott, a Christian who claims to have inside knowledge of when the world will end. To vindicate himself and "defeat" the atheists, he prepares a presentation based on a Bible study he finds in the library.

Daniel (David A.R. White), a young Christian attending a public high school, feels like his religion places too many restrictions on him and wishes to have some freedom from Bible teachings so he can be more popular and date the girl he likes. One night Daniel wishes that he had "never become a believer," and the next day he has a rude awakening: